A small hamlet in the Town of Isli, in Suffolk County, NY, Bay Shore is located on the southern side of Long Island. Purchased from the Secatogue Native Americans in 1708, the hamlet was known by a variety of names until 1868, when it was officially designated Bay Shore. During this era, the hamlet became known as a resort town and was popular with rich New Yorkers looking for an escape. With its rich history and great location, Bay Shore remains a popular spot for locals and tourists alike.
Check out 300 Bay Shore, NY rent to own homes for sale, which may include auction properties, for sale by owner, and more.
Historic Architecture! Along a stretch of road known as the Montauk Highway, you can visit mansions and estates that date back to the 1880's. Tales of hauntings and dramatic lifestyles abound in these beautiful examples of historical architecture. You can visit the W.H. Wray House, the Hulse House or the Gustavino Tile House.
The Waterfront! Located on the south side of Long Island, Bay Shore sits right on the Great South Bay. Down at the Bay Shore Marina you can eat, visit the small beach, head over to Shipwreck Cove Spray Park and even dock your boat if you are so inclined.
Great for Renters! With a welcoming 40 percent of renters living in Bay Shore, finding a great place for short term rentals or rent to own properties is easy. Popular neighborhoods for rentals are West Bay Shore, Union Blvd and Commack Rd.
Rising Home Appreciation! With appreciation rates rising 4.3 percent in the past year and 6.8 percent in the past two years, Bay Shore has proven to be a great place to find a home. Over 90 percent of homeowners are staying in their homes for longer than a year. The neighborhoods of Bay Wood, Howells Rd and Bay Shore Rd have seen the highest percentage of appreciation in the past year.
Delicious restaurants! If you are looking for a nice restaurant overlooking the water, head over to Molly Malone's Pub and Restaurant for a relaxing brunch outside. If you are looking for some authentic Italian food, head over to Frank and Maria's Italian Pork Store. Originally just a meat market, it now offers authentic Italian cuisine. With over 120 choices, you can find anything you are in the mood to eat.
Fire Island! Bay Shore is a hub for folks looking to visit the outer islands of Long Island such as Fire Island or Jones Beach. You can catch a ferry to Fire Island from Bay Shore to visit Ocean Beach, Fair Harbor or Kismet.
to get full property details for our rent to own homes
(including price and contact info).
By clicking "Continue" I agree to: (1) be contacted at the phone number provided (consent is not a
condition to purchase services) and via email by HousingList.com or
Third Parties about this property and to present
credit related offers by phone, including pre-recorded messages, text, and/or automatic telephone
dialing system; and (2) HousingList.com's