Rent to own Homes in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island, NY is a great place for affordable rent-to-own homes! With the current housing shortage trend it can make it harder to become a homeowner, including in Shelter Island, NY. This means higher than average down payments for homes and higher qualification standards for conventional home loans. With a rent-to-own property, tenants are also buyers. You can live in the house for a set amount of time before you purchase it, meaning that you get to know the house, your neighbors, and your community before making the final purchase. This enables you and your family to make the right choice based on both information and experience. Rent-to-own is also a great alternative way to get into a home if you have bad credit or don't have enough saved for a down payment.

Check out Shelter Island, NY rent to own homes for sale, which may include auction properties, for sale by owner, and more.
Showing 1 - 44 of 440
Hot
1 of 37 196 CHESTER ST
Rent To Own
New London Civic Center
Single Family Home
New London, CT 06320
2
2
864 ft2
1988
New
16 FENBROOK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Fenwick
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
5
3036 ft2
2007
24 SEABREEZE RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Knollwood
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
2
1952 ft2
1944
New
2 TRAILS END
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
3
2511 ft2
1986
17 FENWICK ST
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
3
1824 ft2
2021
1 of 39 11 UNCAS TRL
Rent to Own Eligible
Saybrook Manor
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
1
988 ft2
1946
New
50 CROMWELL PL
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
3
2433 ft2
1977
49 BISCAYNE BLVD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
2
1190 ft2
1971
17 CROMWELL CT
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2775 ft2
1965
125 SHORE RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
2
2
1476 ft2
1926
78 HARTFORD AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
1
890 ft2
1930
New
29 W SHORE DR
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
2
2510 ft2
1945
New
26 BROOKSIDE AVE W
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
2
1
800 ft2
1945
270 MILE CREEK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
3
1589 ft2
1978
275 SEASIDE AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
2
3
1155 ft2
1900
24 OAKRIDGE DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
3
1864 ft2
1977
7 DOLPHIN AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
1
2
720 ft2
1953
60 CAPTAINS DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1279 ft2
1965
1 of 2 51 TROLLEY RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
2
1
962 ft2
1920
New
10 MAMACOCK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
3
2
1577 ft2
1935
New
6 HILLCREST CT
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2972 ft2
1978
New
34 BROWNS LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
3
2146 ft2
1977
New
70 OLD MAIL TRL
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
4
3
1593 ft2
2009
896 BOSTON POST RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1904 ft2
2010
1 of 25 184 SPENCER PLAINS RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1491 ft2
1969
7 WHITECAP RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
4
2
1314 ft2
1930
5 MCCURDY RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
4
4805 ft2
1700
New
6 HOLLY DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2396 ft2
1976
1 of 111 23 MEADOWBROOK ROAD EXT
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1914 ft2
1980
New
117 EDGE HILL RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
2
1
1320 ft2
1988
65 SPRINGBROOK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
3
3098 ft2
1985
1 of 25 3 VILLAGE LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
4
4012 ft2
2004
510 MCVEAGH RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Townhouse/Condo
Westbrook, CT 06498
4
4
1916 ft2
1961
17 LOOP RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Clinton, CT 06413
4
4
3917 ft2
2017
New
23 HALF PENNY LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
4
2610 ft2
1970
1 of 20 16 WILD APPLE LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2063 ft2
1976
1 of 14 280 E Main St
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Townhouse/Condo
Clinton, CT 06413
2
1
1155 ft2
1965
New
4 NORTH DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
3
4
1752 ft2
2019
157 PETTIPAUG RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
4
3
1400 ft2
1963
1 of 8 166 W MAIN ST
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
2
1
1382 ft2
1939
184 W MAIN ST #C
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Townhouse/Condo
Niantic, CT 06357
2
1
840 ft2
1973
3 NORTH AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
3
2
1616 ft2
1900
Map
Sponsored Link

More Shelter Island, NY Property Resources

Rent to own Homes in Cities Near Shelter Island, NY

Browse all Rent to own Homes in New York

Neighborhoods in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island rent to own homes

Popular Zip Codes in Shelter Island, NY

11964 rent to own homes

Buying a Home in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island, NY is seeing rapid growth and Shelter Island, NY's' housing market remains not optimal with an average home price that is 294% above the 2024 national average. Shelter Island, NY is part of Suffolk county and taxes are an important factor to consider when purchasing a home whether through rent to own or a traditional purchase. The average tax rate as of 2024 for county Suffolk is 1.7% which is above the national average, which is 0.99%.

Median Home Price in Shelter Island, NY

Median Rent in Shelter Island, NY

Median rent data is currently unavailable.
Rent to own homes offer low monthly payments and flexible terms.