Rent to own Homes in Shelter Island, New York, NY

If you have been looking to move into the Shelter Island neighborhood in New York, but found the current housing market to be too restrictive, then a rent-to-own home is perfect for you! Currently, mortgage rates are the highest they've been in decades. Combine that with a general lack of affordable houses to begin with and it's not long before a new path to homeownership needs to be an option. For you, that could be a rent-to-own home in Shelter Island. With a rent-to-own home you can live in the home during a predetermined lease period with rent payments being applied toward the eventual purchase of the home, if you decide it is the right home for you. This gives you time to learn the ins and outs of the home, as well as decide if Shelter Island is the right neighborhood for you.
Check out Shelter Island, New York, NY rent to own homes for sale, which may include auction properties, for sale by owner, and more.
Showing 1 - 44 of 440
Hot
1 of 37 196 CHESTER ST
Rent To Own
New London Civic Center
Single Family Home
New London, CT 06320
2
2
864 ft2
1988
16 FENBROOK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Fenwick
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
5
3036 ft2
2007
Hot New
506 MAPLE AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
Fenwick
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
3938 ft2
1954
24 SEABREEZE RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Knollwood
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
2
1952 ft2
1944
2 TRAILS END
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
3
2511 ft2
1986
36 W END DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
2
686 ft2
1938
17 FENWICK ST
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
3
1824 ft2
2021
New
126 OLD SEA LN
Rent to Own Eligible
Saybrook Manor
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
1
604 ft2
1947
New
367 MAIN ST #4
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Townhouse/Condo
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
2
1042 ft2
1980
New
9 UNCAS TRL
Rent to Own Eligible
Saybrook Manor
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
1
624 ft2
1952
49 BISCAYNE BLVD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
2
1190 ft2
1971
17 CROMWELL CT
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2775 ft2
1965
152 N COVE RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
2
3
2256 ft2
1994
New
48 MEADOWOOD LN
Rent to Own Eligible
Saybrook Manor
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
2
1666 ft2
1966
29 W SHORE DR
Rent to Own Eligible
Old Saybrook Center
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
2
2510 ft2
1945
New
10 ALLENDALE RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Saybrook Manor
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
3
2
1300 ft2
1969
New
11 CHAMPLAIN DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
3
1591 ft2
1972
New
26 BROOKSIDE AVE W
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
2
1
800 ft2
1945
270 MILE CREEK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
3
1589 ft2
1978
24 OAKRIDGE DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
3
1864 ft2
1977
7 DOLPHIN AVE
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
1
2
720 ft2
1953
60 CAPTAINS DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1279 ft2
1965
1 of 2 51 TROLLEY RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
2
1
962 ft2
1920
New
10 MAMACOCK RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
3
2
1577 ft2
1935
6 HILLCREST CT
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2972 ft2
1978
New
34 BROWNS LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
3
3
2146 ft2
1977
70 OLD MAIL TRL
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
4
3
1593 ft2
2009
896 BOSTON POST RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1904 ft2
2010
New
1259 OLD CLINTON RD
Rent to Own Eligible
Westbrook Center
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
1
1200 ft2
1953
7 WHITECAP RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
4
2
1314 ft2
1930
1 of 25 184 SPENCER PLAINS RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1491 ft2
1969
New
1257 OLD CLINTON RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
1
2
516 ft2
1930
New
6 HOLLY DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2396 ft2
1976
1 of 111 23 MEADOWBROOK ROAD EXT
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Westbrook, CT 06498
3
3
1914 ft2
1980
117 EDGE HILL RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
2
1
1320 ft2
1988
New
25 LOOP RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Clinton, CT 06413
5
3
3202 ft2
1928
1 of 25 3 VILLAGE LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Lyme, CT 06371
4
4
4012 ft2
2004
17 LOOP RD
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Clinton, CT 06413
4
4
3917 ft2
2017
New
23 HALF PENNY LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
4
2610 ft2
1970
1 of 20 16 WILD APPLE LN
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
4
3
2063 ft2
1976
1 of 14 280 E Main St
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Townhouse/Condo
Clinton, CT 06413
2
1
1155 ft2
1965
New
4 NORTH DR
Rent to Own Eligible
 
Single Family Home
Niantic, CT 06357
3
4
1752 ft2
2019
Map
Sponsored Link

More Shelter Island Rent to own Home Resources

Rent to own Homes in Other Neighborhoods in New York, NY

Browse all Rent to own Homes in New York, NY
Things to Do in New York, NY
There are a few things to do in New York since the city is smaller both in size and population. Here's a list of fun and popular things to do and places to go.
  • Popular restaurants: Canyon Road Bar & Grill, Le Pain Quotidien, Artichoke Pizza, Botte Ues, Harvest Chinese & Thai Cuisine